This year’s Super Bowl marks the 25th anniversary of New Kids on the Block’s Super Bowl XXV halftime show, an event less notable for the performance than the performer; the boy band would become the first pop act to perform at the NFL championship, marking the first of what became a staple of the event.

To celebrate this anniversary, music columnist Brett Weiser-Schlesinger created a playlist of songs from each of the last 25 Super Bowl halftime performances.